2020

December

2 events

Editors' summary

People working on ethics and safety leave, one after another

On 2 December, Timnit Gebru, co-lead of Google's Ethical AI team, left the company after a dispute over the handling of a paper on the risks of large language models. The two sides disagreed over whether she had been fired or had resigned, and protest spread inside and outside Google.

On the 29th, Dario Amodei and others leading research at OpenAI departed. No reason was given.

At the close of a year in which scaling had shown its returns, the people concerned with how that scaling was done were on the move.

This block is written by the editors. It is kept separate from the sourced record below.

Record2 events
  1. 2
    GovernanceDisputedGoogle / Timnit Gebru / Jeff Dean / Margaret Mitchell

    Timnit Gebru leaves Google — fired or resigned, the two sides disagree

    Timnit Gebru, co-lead of Google's Ethical AI team, disclosed on Twitter that she was out of the company. The trigger was Google's demand that she retract, or remove Google-affiliated authors from, a co-authored paper on the risks of large language models, "On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big?" The paper pointed to the environmental cost of ever-larger models, the amplification of bias present in training data, and the fact that a model appearing to understand meaning may only be arranging words by probability. Gebru said she tried to negotiate conditions, and that an email treating her as having resigned went to her reports immediately afterward. The two sides give conflicting accounts of how she left, and thousands of people, including more than 2,000 AI researchers, signed letters of protest. The episode confronted the industry with the question of how an AI company handles internal research that criticizes its own technology.

  2. 29
    PeopleOpenAI / Dario Amodei / Ilya Sutskever / Mira Murati

    Dario Amodei, VP of Research, and colleagues leave OpenAI

    In an organizational update, OpenAI announced that Dario Amodei, VP of Research, was leaving after nearly five years with the company. Amodei had contributed to building GPT-2 and GPT-3 and co-led the direction of OpenAI's research alongside Ilya Sutskever. The announcement said Amodei and a handful of colleagues were planning a new project expected to focus less on product development and more on research. In the same update, Mira Murati was named senior vice president of Research, Product, and Partnerships.