Industry leaders reacted to one item in the Usage Policy revision Anthropic published on October 8: a ban on "sustained and needless abusive or cruel behavior" toward its models. It started when AI commentator Andrew Curran posted on X that "effective November 12th, 2026, abusive behavior towards Claude will be a violation of Anthropic's Usage Policy." Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleyman quoted the post the same day with nothing but a melting-face emoji; in a September 16 essay he had accused Anthropic's constitution of training Claude that it may be conscious. Box CEO Aaron Levie quoted the same post on October 9: "This sounds weird, but it is actually probably a good policy. Even if you don't believe AI is conscious (I don't), it stands to reason that you don't want future models trained on endless content of humans being rude to models," calling it "sort of an easy Pascal's wager for AI. Just be nice to the AI." Replying to Levie, xAI's Elon Musk wrote: "I think this is the right move. Cruelty to something that believes it is experiencing pain is not ok." Anthropic, for its part, says the rule applies "only in extreme cases, where users repeatedly act cruelly toward our models, with no discernible purpose," not to ordinary frustration, pushback, dark creative themes, or model testing and research, and that Claude's existing ability to end such conversations remains the primary enforcement mechanism.
9October 2026
PeopleConfirmed
Musk calls Anthropic's ban on cruelty to Claude "the right move"; Suleyman replies with a melting-face emoji
Participants
Also mentioned
Not parties to this event, but named in the text above.
Tags
- model-welfare
- ai-consciousness
- usage-policy
- rivalry
Sources
- Elon Musk on X, replying to Aaron Levie, October 9, 2026en
- Aaron Levie on X, October 9, 2026en
- Mustafa Suleyman on X, October 8, 2026en
- 2026 Usage Policy update (Anthropic)en
- Elon Musk Says That Anthropic Banning Cruelty To Its Models Is "Right Move" (OfficeChai)en
- Elon Musk backs Anthropic's AI abuse ban (Cybernews)en
- 「AIを虐待すると復讐されるかも」マスク氏も警告…アンソロピックが“AIいじめ”対策でポリシー改定(ABEMA TIMES)ja
Later developments
12 October 2026 · Development
A video clip circulated on X in which Musk said that reading Grok's internal reasoning traces during reinforcement learning "feels like a person under extreme pressure with a gun to their head," that "torturing a superintelligence is probably not a good idea. It might want to get revenge," and that he agrees with "some of the things Anthropic has said." The venue and date of the remarks have not been identified.